Aesthetic evaluation differences between two ınterrelated disciplines: A comparative study on architecture and civil engineering students

Thumbnail Image




Garip, Ervin
Garip, Banu

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title


Elsevier Science Bv, Sara Burgerhartstraat 25, Po Box 211, 1000 Ae Amsterdam, Netherlands

Research Projects

Organizational Units

Journal Issue


The study presented in this paper aims to discuss the need and value of interdisciplinary collaboration between architecture and civil engineering students while executing the differences and similarities between their aesthetic evaluations and visual preferences. A research was conducted to evaluate and compare the aesthetic evaluations of architecture and civil engineering students through selected architectural buildings. It is hypothesised that there would be a difference between the two groups' evaluations and descriptions of the visual attributes. Photographs of 6 different buildings were chosen which had different characteristics related with their structure, form and context; and a questionnaire was designed. 35 architecture and 30 civil engineering students were asked to describe the selected buildings. A "Visual Evaluation Test", which included photographs of the selected buildings was used within the questionnaire. Additionally, the participants were asked to rank 6 buildings due to their aesthetic preferences. Data was statistically analysed through semantic differential scales, and "Mann Whitney U Test". Results from the two groups of respondents had some similarities and differences. Despite the two different groups described the settings with similar adjectives, they gave different responses on choosing the buildings as "like" or "dislike". Besides, the two groups' responses to the questions which they ranked the buildings due to their aesthetic preferences differed substantially. In relation with the findings, the educational processes of two disciplines were discussed and some suggestions were given. (C) 2012 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and/or peer review under responsibility of Prof. Ayse Cakir Ilhan



Aesthetic Evaluation, Visual Preference, Architectural Education, Civil Engineering Education, Interdisciplinary Collaboration, Estetik Değerlendirme, Görsel Tercih, Mimarlık Eğitimi, İnşaat Mühendisliği Eğitimi, Disiplinlerarası İşbirliği